Skip to content

If It Works As Well As a Drug, It May Be One

Products to treat erectile dysfunction (ED) remain extremely popular online, and so many federal agencies around the world search the internet for products that are dangerous or otherwise illegal. Because card brands may issue fines based on the warnings and alerts issued by regulatory bodies around the world, it's important for payment service providers to keep abreast of regulatory warnings regarding ED products.

In Japan, the Japanese Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare (MHLW) and local governments routinely conduct tests on supplements they purchase from the internet for the purpose of detecting tainted products. The suspected products are mainly so-called "health foods" touted for their tonic effects or slimming effects, and are typically sold on websites that list an offshore business address - if they list contact information at all, which is mandated by Japan's Specified Commercial Transactions Act.

These test buys often reveal supplements that are laced with active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) such as sildenafil and tadalafil, which are typically used to treat ED. MHLW publishes the results of their annual testing, listing the name of products found to be tainted, and warns the public to avoid taking these supplements, as the potential health hazards are significant with these undeclared pharmaceutical ingredients. In some cases, the detected amounts of APIs were considerably higher than what is typically included in approved pharmaceuticals.

It is not just supplements - typically in capsule or tablet form - that are routinely found to contain undeclared APIs. Several food items have been found to be tainted. For example, a line of coffee marketed as "coffee for men" was found to contain undeclared APIs typically used to treat ED. Supplements or food products that are marketed as having the effects of pharmaceuticals warrant additional scrutiny.

Many supplements sold online are shipped from overseas under the guise of an often-misunderstood rule called "personal importation." In this context, the consumer is directly importing something for their personal use; however, the rule does not apply because the product being purchased is something that is unpermitted to cross the border because it lacks appropriate safeguards. Therefore, the consumer is assuming various risks associated with the act of purchasing, including risk to their health.

The personal importation justification is often used by rogue internet pharmacies targeting Japanese customers to sell not only unapproved prescription drugs and tainted supplements, but also e-liquids that contain nicotine, cosmetics that contain problematic ingredients, and highly controlled medical devices such as contact lenses.

The marketing of unapproved drugs and unauthorized medical devices would be a violation of the Pharmaceutical and Medical Device Act in Japan, and would pose elevated risk of BRAM and GBPP fines to payment service providers. LegitScript continuously monitors the internet space for unapproved pharmaceuticals, including tainted supplements, to safeguard the public and help members of the payments industry avoid merchants engaged in problematic activity.

 

Want to learn about other problematic supplement ingredients? Download LegitScript's free guide, Top 10 Problematic Supplement Ingredients to Avoid.

 

Recent Blog Articles

Industry Experts Talked About These Three Key Issues at the Marketplace Risk Global Summit

The Marketplace Risk Global Summit, which took place this month in London, provided a space for the experts, founders, and industry leaders of online platforms to share their experiences, strategies, and forward-thinking solutions to the most pressing challenges in risk management, trust & safet...

FTC Payments Enforcement Trends: Key Takeaways for Payment Service Providers

The Federal Trade Commission continues to scrutinize the payments ecosystem, viewing these companies as critical gatekeepers in the fight against consumer fraud. LegitScript's recent webinar, FTC Payments Enforcement Trends: What Merchant Acquirers and Payment Service Providers Need to Know, examine...

Navigating AI’s Gray Areas: Why Human Oversight Still Matters

Artificial intelligence is changing the way organizations identify risk, monitor compliance, and make policy decisions. But as the technology evolves, so does the challenge of knowing where its limits lie. During a recent panel at Marketplace Risk NYC, Tom Cook, Chief Product and Technology Officer,...

LegitScript Marketplace Risk NYC Panel Recap: AI Blind Spots: The Gray Areas of Risk, Policy & Regulation

AI agents are transforming workflow automation, bringing speed, scale, and intelligence to complex processes. Think of them as well-read interns: capable but inexperienced, requiring context and human judgment. As their role expands, how do we ensure automation enhances, rather than replaces, though...