Skip to content

When is a Legal Dietary Supplement Illegal?

Most countries have regulatory authorities like the Food and Drug Administration that monitor and establish rules around food, drugs, dietary supplements, and more. These agencies have their own complex laws and regulatory standards, and they often vary substantially. What may be a legal, unregulated ingredient in one country is a prescription drug in another, and perhaps an unapproved drug in a third. This can be a headache for business owners who sell food, drugs, or dietary supplements on a global scale.

Take for example Rauvolfia serpentina, which is a flower native to India and Indonesia. It is an ingredient frequently sold in the US to support healthy blood pressure levels and maintain healthy weight. The ingredient is sold on its own as a powder, liquid, or capsules, and is also sold in dietary supplements as one of a blend of ingredients. Products with Rauvolfia serpentina are readily available in the US on major platforms such as Amazon and Google Shopping, as shown below.

Although Rauvolfia serpentina is a generally permissible ingredient in the United States, it is regulated in many other countries. It is a prescription-only ingredient in Australia, Canada, Germany, the UK, and Ireland. And it is an unpermitted ingredient in dietary supplements in Brazil, South Korea, The Netherlands, and Thailand. This means that a business owner selling products that contain Rauvolfia serpentina either must not sell to these countries or must sell in accordance with each country's regulations (and, as appropriate, be properly licensed to dispense the product).

Another example of a globally confusing ingredient is Tribulus terrestris, a plant that grows around the world and has been consumed for a wide range of uses, including maintaining circulatory and sexual health. Although it is a generally permissible ingredient in the United States, many other countries regulate it. In Ireland, Tribulus terrestris is a prescription-only ingredient, and in Brazil it is unpermitted in dietary supplements. Furthermore, under Japanese law, at least one part of the Tribulus terrestris plant is an active pharmaceutical ingredient, and so supplements that contain the ingredient but don't specify which part of the plant it uses are impermissible because of the ambiguity.

Furthermore, Tribulus terrestris products can be globally problematic if they are marketed with problematic disease claims (such as claims to treat erectile dysfunction) or unsubstantiated structure/function claims (such as claims to increase testosterone). These claims cannot be made either on a product's packaging or on the website through which the product is sold.

Business owners who sell dietary supplements that are legal in the US may fail to consider the complex rules and regulations in other countries. Shipping products to countries where they are impermissible or regulated can result in fines or, in extreme cases, the loss of a merchant account. It's important to know every ingredient in every product you sell, and how those ingredients are regulated where they are sold.

LegitScript has the world's largest database of problematic products sold on the internet, including dietary supplements, designer drugs, pharmaceuticals, medical devices, cosmetics, and more. Our database is international, covering regulatory information from more than 50 countries and 100 government agencies. Product classifications can be global or country-specific so you know what products are permissible and where. Contact us to learn more about our product database.

David Khalaf is a writing, communications, and marketing professional with specialties in media, investigations, content strategy, and writing instruction. His 20 years of writing, media, and communications work have included two top-tier universities (USC and UCLA), print and digital magazines, consulting firms, and technology companies.

His current work involves content strategy and development at LegitScript, a company that helps the world's leading search engines, payment service providers, and internet platforms and marketplaces do business with legitimate, legally operating entities in more than 80 countries and 15 languages around the world. LegitScript specializes in risk and compliance for highly regulated industries including CBD/cannabis, online gambling, cryptocurrencies, drugs, financial trading, online adult, scams and fraud, and more.

Recent Blog Articles

ai abuse

AI Abuse Among the Top Payments Risks for 2025

The risk and compliance space for payment processing and e-commerce is dynamic. LegitScript uses its monitoring data and regulatory expertise to track trends across the commercial internet, and we compile and share our findings in our biennial high-risk trends guide. Learn more about AI abuse, one o...
counterfeit goods

Understanding the Coded Terminology of Counterfeit Goods in E-commerce

Illicit counterfeit sales are a multi-trillion-dollar scourge on the global marketplace - and hiding in plain sight. While getting duped by fake products is an increasingly frustrating reality for nearly 70% of online shoppers, a recent study found that over half of consumers knowingly bought counte...
What You Need to Know About The Australian Government’s Scams Prevention Framework.

What You Need to Know About The Australian Government’s Scams Prevention Framework

In 2023, bad actors stole 2.7 billion from consumers - and the Australian government acted quickly to propose protections. "The Scams Prevention Framework [...] is an economy-wide reform to protect the Australian community from scams. It recognises that a whole-of-ecosystem approach is required to r...
merchant risk solution

How a Third-party Merchant Risk Monitoring Solution Can Help

According to LegitScript's latest Benchmarking Report, 81% of survey participants use a merchant monitoring service provider (MMSP) to mitigate risk. And that number is growing year over year. Third-party merchant risk monitoring solutions vary but LegitScript Merchant Risk Solutions leverage regula...